Sunday, March 9, 2008

It all comes back to the story

While I don’t agree with everything Pink says, one of his six senses, story, has been “following me everywhere” this past week. I figured I’m especially attune to this because I’m also taking Storytelling right now. But since the last two posts by Emily and Mary also convey storytelling as it relates to gaming and capturing people’s thoughts and news events, I figured I’m not the only one thinking about it. I appreciated the Jonathan Harris video. He explains that he is a storyteller in that he conveys other people’s stories. Stories can show we have a lot in common with people around the world, even with many kinds of cultural and other “gaps” as Harris puts it. We have a need to express ourselves. Pink also writes about how integral story is to the human experience. Our lives are filled with sharing stories. Stories include telling about events that have happened to us. They can convey not only the events, but also our feelings about the event, about ourselves, and the world. I think most importantly, storytelling is not just explaining, but recreating the experience for the listeners. I often use personal stories to connect with others. I typically tell stories to my elementary students as teaching tools as well as to simply share myself with them. I also listen to their stories to learn about them. With friends and family, we use stories to make connections, to entertain, and to evoke emotion, including sympathy.

With my students, the more personal the story is, the more they are enthralled, especially if it has some humor. Yes, teaching theory says a teacher needs to connect her teaching to the students’ lives, not her own. In my teacher education program I was also advised not to tell my students too much about my personal life in order to maintain a professional, authoritative image. Yet, teaching is all about celebrating the stories of our lives and the lives of others, past, present, and future. What better way to teach than to share personal stories with my students?

A recent example occurred when I was reading from our social studies textbook with my third graders. We have been learning about communities, and the pages we were reading described the words “custom” and “culture.” The concept of “culture” is something even I can struggle with, so this was no easy concept to explain. It was also hard for them to recognize that some activities they take for granted and assume that everyone does are actually a part of our culture, and other people may do it differently. I gave the example of greeting each other. I asked them what action adults might do to greet each other, to which they responded, “shake hands.” I explained that not every culture does this, and launched into a story about myself. When I lived in the Dominican Republic, I quickly discovered that women always greet each other by offering a kiss on the cheek. It was explained to me that this wasn’t actually a kiss where your lips touch the other person, but more of an air kiss. What wasn’t explained to me was that it only is done on the right cheek, never the left. One morning I was greeting a parent and leaned in for the air kiss, but I was heading toward her left. She, of course, was heading towards my right and turning her left side away from me, so my nose crashed into her face! This little story grabbed all the students’ attention, and helped them grasp a little better the concept of customs and the importance of learning about others’ customs!

I could tell that some of the students were left thinking that other people sure had strange customs. I tried to think of a way to get them to see that our customs also might appear strange to others. Then I shared a different kind of story, not a personal story but one to encourage them to see from another perspective. I invited them to imagine they were coming to our school from another planet. They had never been to earth before. Our principal, would reach out his hand to shake theirs, but they would have no idea what he was doing! Are we supposed to reach out a hand too? Left or right? Then what to do next? Students quickly grasped that shaking hands does not come to people naturally, and not everyone does it, but it is one of the customs we use in our American culture.

My students also share stories about themselves, which enriches the classroom as a community and a learning environment. Children are extremely eager to share stories about themselves. I encourage them to connect stories from their lives to what we are learning about or reading. For example, when they connect books they are reading to their own story – what they’ve seen, their adventures, and day-to-day experiences – they are much better able to create meaning from what they are learning about. Stories that connect to your own stories build not only attention, but a stronger emotional charge. Not only will you enjoy the story more, but it can then affect you more deeply and stay with you longer.

These are kinds of storytelling that I feel happen naturally in my life working with youth. I’d like to stretch beyond these kinds of things and think about how I can incorporate media and media literacy with storytelling. Since children are already eager to share stories, I think they would love to create digital stories. I’m certainly no expert in creating digital stories, and in fact, was extremely frustrated with technology when I created my resource review as a video, using JumpCut, a free online editor through Yahoo. If I were going to teach students about creating digital stories, it would be important for me to be very comfortable with the technology and help the students feel comfortable with it too, because the technology needs to be secondary to the storytelling.

Here are some more sites to explore about using storytelling and young people, both digital and nondigital, besides the Bernard site:

From the Center for Digital Storytelling: Memory's Voices, especially The Cookbook section.

Storytelling and youth: An emerging force for social change in communities.

Huffaker, David "Spinning Yarns Around the Digital Fire:" compares blogs/IMing, etc. to storytelling since they provide space to share ideas and feelings. Interesting, if a little old (2003).

20 page source book full of Activities to help youth filmmakers think about all aspects of production.

4 comments:

cynthia said...

Becky,
I read your Storytelling blog with interest. I really feel in regard to your teacher education that claims a teacher must keep their personal details out of the classroom is a very limited approach in today's world, where empathy and example can be used as a great teaching tool. Your culture example was a very good one. I think we see this storytelling effectively, too, when we have visitors at our school that can humanize what they do. Very recently, I had the opportunity to sit in with some of the visiting authors and illustrators that came to our district. One author in particular told the students how he became a writer, what he was like when he was little, and made a great statement at the end where he told the kids, "See, Im just like you, you could end up a writer like me if you want."

We need to also be aware that storytelling is also effective in advertising and selling, i.e., a manipulative tool. Again, it's all about becoming discerning.

I also enjoyed the video you linked about the blogs/stories of the masses and "feelings".
What I found most UNsurprising was the age range of all this writing. I have closets full of writings from my 20's that I am oh,so glad that no one ever read but me. It's great to empathize and see that others have a similiar story to my own, but can I also use that as a crutch for my situation? Gee, it looks like zillions of people have my addiction/problem, so I guess it's just the way we are! Misery does love company!

An interesting project, never the less. Thanks for sharing.

Becky Schaller said...

Cynthia, I think "limited approach" is a good description of the idea teachers should keep quiet about personal information. Certainly there is something to be said about keeping a professional distant (although I'm not totally sure what that means). But there are lots of stories you can tell that about yourself and still keep a professional distance. I think the story Becky told is an excellent example of an appropriate story. They learn a little about the teacher and the focus is on the lesson.
Becky S

cynthia said...

Becky,
Here's a lesson plan for younger grades from the Read Write Think website that actually incorporates getting to know what the teacher does when she/he's not in the classroom! I thought you might appreciate it.
http://www.readwritethink.org/lessons/lesson_view.asp?id=174

Nell said...

Here is a nice and complex definition of Culture for you: http://www.tamu.edu/classes/cosc/choudhury/culture.html

And here is a more simplified example relating to Deaf Culture. http://deafness.about.com/cs/deafculture/a/deafculture101.htm

I also like Wikipedia's site as well. You can use criteria in a list to compare cultures:

language
religion
Attire
Food
Dance/Music
Social Trends/rules

There are some definitions that vary, with a certain number of criteria necessary to distinguish between a culture and a sub culture as well.

I studied about culture in depth in Interpreter training school so it is something I am intimately familiar with. I find that concrete examples and comparisons work well for me to understand a concept like culture.

Interesting blog debating the definitions of Deaf culture (ASL culture) http://carl-schroeder.blogspot.com/2007/12/what-is-your-definition-of-deaf-culture.html